
Alexey Brodovitch, the visionary art director at Harper's Bazaar in the 1930s to the 1950s, egged young Richard Avedon: "Astonish me!" Photographs can't be just good or even perfect. They have to astonish the viewer. No matter how sophisticated the viewer is, the photographer must find that angle, that perception, that once-in-a-lifetime composite of light, shapes and emotion, that boggles the mind. To astonish is not so complex but harder to accomplish than we can imagine.
Astonishment is to my mind that quality of experience when every object in our mind's eye shimmers with unadulterated delight. What adulterates it? Every other feeling. The image possesses its own emotion, the capacity to cause feelings to arise in the viewer but to create the image demands sincerity beyond the ordinary. We must lose ourselves in the imagination. We can't stay in our little world and expect to find God there. To be astonished is to experience God as others have known him so many other times before.
In Buddhist terms, to experience God is to experience the elemental. Asian philosophers write about the five elements—earth, air, fire, water and space. Of these is everything we experience composed. Practicing meditation one examines what appears to be whole but is really just a composite of past experiences that keeps us from seeing dynamic nowness. Now is eternally moving. It is nowhere because when we grasp at the moment it is gone.
"Do you know the word 'temporary'?
It means 'only for a little while.'"
John Buccino's little collection of songs, Grateful, is one of my favorites. In the song, Temporary, he hits upon the same theme I am writing about today.
"Everything is temporary...
If you learn this though
You won't feel so sad:
A playmate, a tearstain
A Christmas, a dad
The best times
The worst pain
All temporary."
In meditation we learn to watch each temporary moment come and go. We learn what earth is, what air, what water, what fire, what space: everything is temporary. A product of the practice is we rediscover astonishment. Accepting and letting go we find each new image suddenly and eternally bathed in the vividness of what I think of as life beyond experience. Each whiff of fragrance, each nub under our fingertip, each curlicue of line, all partakes of a brilliance that photographs only aspire to possess.
The heart of experience seems to me best described only in paradoxes. No wonder teachers of old spoke in riddles or parables. Between the polarities of yes and now there lies only appearance. To get to the underlying reality we must forego the easy path of holding on to what is temporary. In the endlessness of space where no feelings find a home we find the adoring face we search for all our lives. It is our own face but not really. We see beyond the appearance to what the finger points to that gives rise to the incessant hunger that drives us relentlessly, ever unsatisfied, foolishly most days.
"I hold the world but as the world, Gratiano,
A stage..."
Thus Antonio explains his sadness to his friend, the merchant in Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice.
When we find amazement our lives spontaneously take on an evangelical thrust. Its shimmer pervades not only our experience but seeps outside it to affect other experiences. If we seek meaning, amazement more than fits the bill. Let go and astonish!